Provided by Anna George-Plunkett
The aim of using a discussion carousel is to create maximum participation, for students to work with students they don’t normally work with and to deepen individual students’ thinking.
In pairs, students label themselves A & B. They face each other and discuss the debate title for 3 minutes. Make sure both students have chance to speak (let them know half time!)
Then when time is up, A partner move to another B partner (who stays sitting down).
Before students launch in to their new conversation developing the conversation further, each one of them has to summarise to the other their previous partner’s contribution.
When time is up, repeat the process with a new partner.
Be prepared to then put these discussion points in to a whole class debate.
Building castles
Aim- To keep students focused in a debate and engage all students in the activity.
You will need a template of a castle and some arrows to “attack” the castle for each group.
Teams of 5.
2 students arguing for, 2 students arguing against, 1 adjudicator (more able student).
Taking it in turns, team A puts forward their point in the debate. If the adjudicator thinks it is justified (PEE), they can build a piece of the castle.
The opposing team (team B) then try to refute that point (PEE). If justified by the adjudicator, the opposing team use an arrow to attack that part of the castle. (Both the castle piece & arrow are left on the table.)
This process continues until the time is up or until the castle is built/completely destroyed.
The adjudicator then has to sum up the arguments made in the debate, evaluating the strengths & weaknesses of the arguments and decide which team has been more successful in the debate.
Castle template


